Jump to
main body

Jump to
animations list

Jump to
discussions list

Jump to
discussions and animations list

Jump to
main body

The Stern-Gerlach Experiment - particles and spin



Mechanism for quantum spin Particles and spin

The Standard model of particle physics models the subatomic matter particles

As quantum waves that have a wave-particle duality

And a quantum spin


In this physics model

A particle of matter is an ordinary particle, that has spin

And that spin is at a continuous constant rate

The following animation shows the shapes and structures of the model's subatomic particles, the  Particles  button steps through the particles, the  Run  button start / stops the animation (any of the buttons can be used in pause mode)

The Subatomic Particles

In this physics model, the elementary strand shaped particle

Is an ordinary three dimensional particle

That moves continuously at a single constant speed, against a static universal reference frame, in three dimensional space


And

The particles of matter are torus shaped particles

Built using the elementary strand shaped particle


With the strand shaped particles inside a particle of matter, moving continuously at a single constant speed

For a particle of matter to move forwards

The particle of matter's perfectly round torus shape has to distort, with the internal strand shaped particles bunching up onto one side or other in the particle of matter's torus ring

The following animation shows the simple electron particle and proton particle changing shape when the particles move, the  Move Forwards  button starts the particles moving forwards, the  Run  button start / stops the animation (any of the buttons can be used in pause mode)

Moving The Matter Particles

The distortion of the particle of matter's tous shape, alters the balance of the particle of matter's internal circular movement

And the particle of matter moves forward

With the plane of the particle of matter's torus ring pointing towards the direction that the particle is moving


In this physics model

A particle of matter can move freely in any direction that is in the plane of its torus ring, by distorting the shape of its torus ring

But not so easily in the directions that are not in the plane of its torus ring


When a particle of matter changes direction to a direction that is not in the plane of its torus ring

Then the particle of matter has to change the plane of its torus ring

To point towards the new direction


Since the inhomogeneous magnetic field of the Stern-Gerlach apparatus changes the beam of electrons from moving horizontally, to moving vertically, i.e. a change in axis

This forces the electrons in the experiment to change the plane of their torus rings to point towards the vertical direction

(In the first version of the experiment, a beam of silver atoms was used rather than a beam of electrons)

The following animation shows the inhomogeneous magnetic field of the Stern-Gerlach experiment, changing the electron's random vertical orientation of the plane of its torus ring, to align with the vertical plane, the  Run  button start / stops the animation (any of the buttons can be used in pause mode)

Stern-Gerlach Experiment

In this physics model, on entering the apparatus

The horizontally moving electrons have the plane of their torus rings aligned to a horizontal orientation

But when the electrons are vertically deflected, the vertical deflection forces each electron to align the plane of its torus ring into the vertical plane, with two possibilities


Either the electron's now vertically aligned torus ring

Is spinning 'clockwise'

With respect to the vertical plane


Or the electron's now vertically aligned torus ring

Is spinning 'anticlockwise'

With respect to the vertical plane


As a suggestion, that is how, in this physics model, the inhomogeneous magnetic field in the Stern-Gerlach experiment

Deflects each electron by a 'quantum amount'

Either as a 'quantum amount down'

Or as a 'quantum amount up'


In this physics model, the cause of the electron's behaviour in the Stern-Gerlach experiment

Is the constant speed of the strand shaped particles

That are inside the electron's torus ring


As a note

A suggestion is required as to what a magnetic field is, in this physics model

As a suggestion, perhaps a magnetic field is an overall neutral electric field that, from each atomic point source of the electric field, the majority of the short positive electric field particles move in one direction, and the majority of the short negative electric field particles move in another direction, the two directions being at an angle to each other

Here is a video that discusses the behaviour the silver atoms / electrons as they pass through the inhomogeneous magnetic field of the apparatus

Here is an old video that discusses electron spin in this physics model

Modern physics discussion on quantum spin Particles and spin

The Standard model of particle physics models the subatomic matter particles

As quantum waves that have a wave-particle duality

And a quantum spin

For reference, here is a YouTube video (2019) by Ryan Steinbach that discusses the Stern-Gerlach experiment

Discussion of the Stern-Gerlach experiment

0 minutes : introduction to electron quantum spin

30 seconds : description of the Stern-Gerlach experiment

1 minutes : detection of the deflected electrons

2 minutes : electron deflection is found to be only 'up' or 'down'

And a copy of an accompanying comment by Ryan Steinbach, explaining why the result of the experiment isn't a case of the magnetic field twisting the orientation of the electron


Totally reasonable point. It turns out that spin is a little more complex than just a magnetic field. It can be better described as "intrinsic angular momentum"

I didn't have the time to get into this in the three minutes, but basically, we know that the orientation doesn't get twisted by the field


Keep in mind, too, that because of the stronger effect of the south magnet, if they were twisting / becoming magnetized by the field, pretty much every electron would go up. Only those facing directly against the field (of which there are likely few or none) would go down. This isn't what we see

That's not to say that measurement doesn't have an effect, just that it's not the effect you're describing


There's a great Looking Glass Universe video that I'll link to here that explains this in better detail

I encourage you to watch it as it addresses your point and helped me clear up some similar confusion!

A  Physics  Model The  Simple  Model The  Simple  Universe